Skip to main content

Posts

Social Mobility: It’s the economy, stupid.

“It’s the economy, stupid,” was the defining slogan of the Clinton presidential campaign in 1992. It was not an idea arising from Clinton himself, but from his very effective campaign leader, James Carville.   The economy was stressed as the key factor in determining the intentions of voters. This is a timeless mantra that is simple to understand.   But Carville is not an economist. As an ex-marine, lawyer and school teacher he was distilling the case for government down to a simple, and perhaps singular, concern of the voters. The economy is the overriding concern of most voters simply because most do not have much of the stuff that comprises the ‘economy’; i.e. money. But is it simply this variable that determines every social outcome? What is Social Mobility? The idea of ‘Social Mobility’ is an increasing concern for voters in the UK, and thus for political leaders. But defining what is meant by ‘Social Mobility’ turns out to be a tougher proposition than expecte...

Scum of the Earth Maybe – but Educated Scum Nevertheless!

He refused me an overdraft with astonishing relish stating: “I don’t see why we should pay to educate scum like you”. I refused to stoop to begging for the right to continue my education and I walked away. The long awaited report of the National Union of Students (NUS) ‘Poverty Commission’ [1] emerged on Monday and reports across the media of its contents raised some eyebrows. Perhaps for the first time, exposed to the light of day, we see the profound absurdity of government ‘schemes’ that are supposed to improve access to higher and further education. The paradox of expecting students from low income backgrounds to succeed, without enough resources to live on, is set against the fallacy of a ‘middle class’ assumption that families will support their offspring ‘come what may’. This is exposed in a comprehensive and detailed report. A fully detailed coverage of it here would never do it justice; it has to be read by all concerned with the futures of our young people. The ana...

The Social Mobility agenda in the UK - Who counts the beans?

When it comes to the merger and governance of the many Higher Education Agencies responsible for promoting and measuring the Social Mobility agenda in the UK. Who counts the beans – the producer or the consumer? If we are to get to grips with the 'Social Mobility' problem, and access and success at universities, we must rely upon, and fully trust, the associated data. The governance of this activity must not only be independent of the institutions, it must be seen to be independent and not reliant upon them in any way. Merger mania. This week sees the further consolidation of agencies tasked with a range of important functions of Higher Education in the UK. To this end, AdvanceHE was formed on 21st March this year [1]. It formalised ongoing plans to merge the Equality Challenge Unit (ECU) [2], the Higher Education Academy (HEA) [3] and the Leadership Foundation for Higher Education (LFHE) [4] under one umbrella. On the face of it, this seems to be a sensib...